Ranking all 14 NFL playoff quarterbacks: Strengths, weaknesses

When the NFL playoffs for the 2022 season kick off Saturday, we are going to see a few of the league’s greatest expertise beneath heart. Eleven of the highest 15 finishers in Whole QBR made the sphere. Eight of the 14 playoff groups’ projected starters had been first-round picks (together with two of the backups). All seven AFC groups might begin quarterbacks beneath the age of 30, and as much as six passers might make their first playoff begin, per ESPN Stats & Info analysis.

These guys will all be huge elements in whether or not their groups go on deep playoff runs, and I see lots of quarterbacks right here who can compete for a Tremendous Bowl title this 12 months.

Ranking all 14 of the beginning signal-callers is not simple. I based mostly the next 1-14 checklist on how every passer is taking part in for the time being and what I anticipate from them as we head to the postseason. I attempted to take away the environment for every quarterback and weigh their skills and up to date kind on their very own, unattached to crew energy, playcalling or supporting forged on offense. That is simply how I’d stack the quarterbacks proper now based mostly on watching every on tape over the course of the season.

The primary identify of the checklist wasn’t too tough to put, however it bought more durable from there.

Mahomes is the Stephen Curry of the NFL. He has a tremendous potential to only sluggish all the pieces down round him and use his immense soccer sense to do just about no matter he needs to do with the soccer, whatever the scenario. He completed the season with a league-leading 77.6 QBR and threw 41 landing passes, his most since an MVP-winning 2018 season. His arm expertise is off the charts, and there is not a lot he cannot do.

I suppose there’s a little concern with him getting too frisky with the soccer at occasions, although. He threw 12 interceptions, one 12 months after throwing 13. There’s some “I’m just going to try this” to his sport, and it isn’t all the time needed. However the factor about Mahomes is he usually pulls it off anyway.


Burrow is not simply taking part in quarterback on the market — he is taking part in in opposition to the protection. He is aware of precisely what is required at any given second and the right way to play in opposition to each opponent. With three seasons beneath his belt, together with a run to final 12 months’s Tremendous Bowl, he sees the sphere higher than anybody in soccer. And he now has back-to-back years with 34 or extra TD throws regardless of mediocre safety in entrance of him.

There aren’t too many flaws along with his sport. I really like what I see on tape just about each weekend from Burrow. His arm energy won’t be on the similar degree as a few of the different QBs listed right here, however he nonetheless accomplished 13 downfield passes (not less than 25 air yards) this season.


No play is useless with Allen beneath heart. He is the NFL’s final playmaker, whether or not it’s along with his speeding potential or large arm. And when Allen is on his sport, he is the most popular quarterback in soccer. Per ESPN Stats & Info analysis, Allen has the most effective TD-to-INT ratio (14-1) in playoff historical past amongst QBs with not less than 150 passing makes an attempt. His 71.2 QBR ranked second this 12 months to Mahomes, and his 7.1 yards per dropback had been fourth.

Allen’s greatest energy will be his greatest weak point, although. He must be taught to curb his competitiveness at occasions. He appears to get into this mode the place he seems like he has to do all of it himself, and it may possibly get him into hassle. His 29 interceptions over the previous two seasons lead the league.


Hurts has a butterfly impact on the remainder of the Eagles’ roster. You’ll be able to simply see how a lot he alters that crew when he is beneath heart, and he creates issues for opposing offenses. Hurts forces opponents to play true 11-on-11 soccer due to precision passing and the flexibility to run the ball like a tailback.

He accomplished 66.5% of his passes this season and solely threw six interceptions, and his 66.7 QBR completed fourth. And solely Jamaal Williams had extra speeding TDs than Hurts’ 13. He can chase the large play an excessive amount of, however then once more, he does have A.J. Brown and DeVonta Smith on the market working routes for him.


Everybody is aware of about Herbert’s large arm and skill to drive the ball. However I feel he’s getting higher along with his eye manipulation, too. That matches the arm expertise at this level. He can maintain or transfer defenders very properly along with his eyes to choose aside the protection and discover voids. A few of his key targets had been injured for stretches this season, however he nonetheless threw 25 TD passes and accomplished 68.2% of his throws.

Herbert can typically be somewhat too by-the-book on the market. By that, I imply he has such spectacular soccer sense that he can truly undergo progressions too quick. He strikes off issues too rapidly, and somewhat bit extra endurance may enable some receivers to come back open.


Is there a participant going through extra stress in these playoffs? I might go as far as to say there hasn’t been one prior to now 10 years. Think about how a lot the Ravens lean on him, how vital this efficiency is for his subsequent contract, how a lot he’s betting on himself and the truth that he has now missed 5 video games in every of the previous two seasons. That mentioned, Jackson is certainly one of in all probability 5 gamers who can flat-out take over the postseason along with his expertise when wholesome. That is game-breaking talent of the Tremendous Bowl caliber. His 64.7 QBR is third since being drafted in 2018 amongst lively QBs, behind simply Mahomes and Allen.

However the accidents might be an element; he hasn’t performed since early December (knee), and there is nonetheless no assure he performs within the wild-card spherical. I additionally do not belief the Ravens’ aerial offense sufficient within the pass-happy AFC playoffs. If Jackson might throw it to himself, I might really feel higher, however the lack of go-to large receivers limits his upside.

play

2:19

Canty: Ravens’ therapy of Lamar disrespectful

Kimberley A. Martin and Chris Canty talk about Lamar Jackson’s unsure future with the Ravens.


Brady is again within the playoffs once more, and you may by no means depend him out. He can nonetheless hit the throws outdoors the numbers in one-on-one conditions. However his landing depend dipped by 18 from final season, and his yards per try (6.4) was his lowest in a season since 2002.

The excellent news for Brady? He will get the ball out quick.

The unhealthy information for Brady? He will get the ball out quick.

With poor offensive line safety this season, Brady has averted stress through the use of the short sport, averaging 2.45 seconds earlier than passing (quickest within the NFL). That is a superb factor, as a result of Brady’s 6.7 QBR beneath stress ranks twenty ninth. However it’s additionally unhealthy as a result of it limits the offense. The Bucs can solely get the ball downfield with play-action, they usually merely do not do it sufficient.


Jones assaults the center of the sphere rather well, displaying some high-end ball placement. His 75.9% completion charge on throws between the hashes ranks second within the NFL. And he has develop into a speeding asset for the Giants’ offense, choosing up simply shy of 600 yards along with his toes in 2022.

I do surprise if his “good” is sweet sufficient, although. Can Jones carry the Giants to a string of playoff wins? The supporting forged does not have the identical expertise as different NFC contenders, so Jones should take over at occasions.


Lawrence is taking part in free proper now. He is a fearless quarterback who will drive you to defend each single blade of grass on the sphere, vertically and horizontally. His TD-to-INT ratio in his rookie 12 months was 12-17, however it jumped to 25-8 in 2022. His completion proportion additionally leapt from sub-60% to 66.3%. Nevertheless, you may nonetheless see some adrenaline-fueled misses. In spite of everything, he is nonetheless solely 23 years previous.


Smith is pretty much as good at going by way of progressions as any of those quarterbacks. He says “no” rapidly when it is not there and strikes on, and he is assured in what his eyes are telling him. That helped him to an NFL-leading 69.8% completion charge and the league’s sixth-best QBR (61.1). However he holds the ball a bit too lengthy, which leads to the next sack depend. He took 46 this season, tied for the third most.


Few quarterbacks have the caliber of supporting forged that Cousins has in Minnesota. That begins with Justin Jefferson, whose presence on the sphere permits him to be extra aggressive. However he is sometimes too aggressive, trusting his eyes an excessive amount of. A streaky quarterback, Cousins has to play to a sure fashion of sport to achieve success. He helped the Vikings to 13 wins, however his 49.8 QBR was twenty third within the league.


This may look low, however Prescott enters the playoffs recent off the worst season of his profession. The ball has simply constantly been within the unsuitable place, and he does not appear to be seeing the sphere clearly. He missed 5 video games earlier within the season, however he nonetheless tied for the league lead in interceptions (15). Prescott has been too fast to depart the pocket, too, not placing sufficient religion within the safety.

However I will say this: Prescott is nails on the market. He has an unwavering mentality, and that may go a good distance within the postseason. And his reference to receiver CeeDee Lamb is excellent.


This is not actually a knock. It is simply an unknown. We’ve not seen Purdy play sufficient to know what he’ll do within the playoffs. However in his restricted time beginning for the Niners, he has for probably the most half identified the place to go together with the soccer. His eyes are constantly in the precise place. His 65.6 QBR would rank fifth within the league if it certified, and he hasn’t misplaced a sport but. However how will he deal with the stress of the postseason? What’s going to occur if/when San Francisco finds itself down 14-0?


Thompson is in line to begin within the wild-card spherical with Tua Tagovailoa dominated out. He’s nonetheless very inexperienced as a seventh-round rookie third-stringer, finishing simply 57.1% of his throws throughout seven video games (two begins) and averaging 5.1 yards per try. However he has some mobility and explosive arm energy. The ball pops off his hand as a thrower, although he typically is overly aggressive and must weave in somewhat extra contact on a few of his passes.


Others who might play

  • Tua Tagovailoa, Miami Dolphins: Tagovailoa is out for the wild-card spherical however might play in some unspecified time in the future if Miami advances. His 68.5 QBR ranked third this season, and he sees issues earlier than they occur. He can throw over or round defenders pretty much as good as anybody within the league, and he has been very environment friendly in his breakout 12 months, averaging 8.9 yards per try (first within the NFL).

  • Teddy Bridgewater, Miami Dolphins: Bridgewater is instinctive and aggressive — but not careless — with the soccer. He’s nonetheless coping with a dislocated pinkie on his throwing hand.

  • Tyler Huntley, Baltimore Ravens: Huntley is an effective rhythmic passer, and whereas he is not Jackson, he nonetheless brings some speeding potential. We’re nonetheless ready on affirmation that Jackson will play within the wild-card spherical.

  • Anthony Brown, Baltimore Ravens: Brown is likely to be compelled into motion if each Jackson and Huntley cannot play within the wild-card spherical. The undrafted rookie has accomplished simply 44.9% of his throws throughout two video games and has but to throw a TD cross.