There’s no query that somebody shot Megan Thee Stallion within the Hollywood Hills in 2020.
Prosecutors have pointed the finger at Canadian hip-hop star Tory Lanez, whose actual identify is Daystar Peterson. They are saying the rapper was drunk and livid with the “Savage” hit-maker, whose actual identify is Megan Pete, after she insulted his profession in a raucous argument inside an SUV.
However throughout a contentious nine-day trial that has been replete with allegations of witness tampering, Peterson’s group has tried to shift the blame towards Pete’s estranged greatest good friend, Kelsey Harris. Lead protection lawyer George Mgdesyan has contended the case was a couple of romantic tryst fairly than a rivalry between rappers, claiming Harris exploded following an alcohol-fueled revelation that each girls had been sleeping with Peterson.
Jurors will now have to decide on between these tales as Peterson’s trial got here to an finish Thursday. He’s charged with assault with a firearm, possession of a hid firearm and reckless discharge of a gun. If convicted on all counts and a pair of sentencing enhancements, he faces as much as 23 years in jail. Harris will not be on trial.
On the finish of the day, after three hours of deliberations, jurors requested for a “better definition” of the phrases “willfully” and “on purpose,” referring to the state’s fees towards Peterson. Earlier, that they had the court docket reporter learn again the total testimony of Sean Kelly, a neighbor who watched the incident unfold from his balcony.
Throughout closing arguments Wednesday, L.A. County Deputy Dist. Atty. Alexander Bott revisited Pete’s emotional testimony from final week, the place the usually swaggering rapper admitted she regretted reporting Peterson to police due to the torrent of criticism she’s gotten from followers and male icons within the hip-hop trade.
“I wish he would’ve just shot and killed me if I knew I was going to have to go through this torture,” Pete, 27, testified.
Closing arguments wrapped up Thursday and Mgdesyan continued to concentrate on testimony from Kelly, the neighbor who testified that he noticed “muzzle flashes” coming from the place a girl was standing, implying Harris pulled the set off.
“[Kelly] has been consistent from the first day,” Mgdesyan stated, calling Kelly the one unbiased eye witness within the case who has no ties to Pete or others.
Mgdesyan additionally emphasised the dearth of forensic proof towards Peterson. DNA exams on the gun used within the capturing had been inconclusive, and Peterson’s DNA was not discovered on the journal that had been inserted into the firearm. He questioned on Thursday why solely Peterson had been examined for DNA, and never Harris or Peterson’s driver, Jaquan Smith.
“If Kelsey Harris’ DNA was on that gun, would we be here today?” Mgdesyan requested jurors. “The lack of DNA itself is reasonable doubt.’ ”
Solely 4 folks noticed what occurred on the July 2020 night time when gunfire erupted within the Hollywood Hills. Pete, Peterson, Harris and Peterson’s driver, Smith, had been inside an SUV leaving an alcohol-fueled occasion at Kylie Jenner’s dwelling.
Peterson declined to take the stand within the case. Though Smith was current in court docket Wednesday, the protection declined to name him after prosecutors requested for a weeklong continuance if he testified. Peterson was involved the delay may trigger a mistrial, Mgdesyan stated. A spokeswoman for the district lawyer’s workplace didn’t reply to questions on why a continuance could be wanted.
The capturing sparked 911 calls, and Los Angeles cops intercepted the car on Hollywood Boulevard a short while later. Dramatic physique digital camera footage confirmed Pete falling down bloody whereas attempting to adjust to police orders, whereas Peterson was pressured to lie face-down and shirtless in the midst of the road. Peterson was later booked on suspicion of possessing an unregistered firearm, however Pete didn’t inform police she had been shot till days later.
Mgdesyan has repeatedly attacked Pete’s credibility, questioning her determination to delay reporting the incident to police and her refusal to confess she’d had a sexual relationship with Peterson till the trial, which he argued is central to the case. Dismissing Pete’s declare she was afraid to cooperate with police, Mgdesyan has argued she was attempting to guard Harris and a jury can not take her at her phrase.
“Megan Pete is a liar. She has lied about everything this case,” Mgdesyan stated, later including that Pete “told you Black women don’t talk to the police, and yet, four days later, she’s talking to the police.”
L.A. County Deputy Dist. Atty. Kathy Ta pushed again on that portrayal Thursday, asking jurors what motive Pete must lie, and reminding the panel of the extreme backlash the performer has confronted since reporting the incident to authorities.
“It would’ve been easier to say, ‘My crazy ex-assistant did this,’ ” Ta stated, referring to Harris.
On the night time of the capturing, Harris despatched a panicked textual content to Pete’s head of safety studying, “Tory shot Meg.” Earlier this yr, she recognized Peterson because the gunman in a recorded interview with prosecutors and echoed Pete’s allegation that Peterson supplied each girls $1 million to not converse to police.
However in court docket final week, Harris walked again most of these statements, saying she was not “100% truthful” within the recorded interview whereas refusing to say what she lied about. Harris was granted restricted immunity for her testimony and spent most of her day on the stand infuriating prosecutors. Los Angeles County Superior Court docket Decide David Herriford ultimately allowed prosecutors to play Harris’ complete recorded interview for jurors, who should now decide which model of her testimony was correct.
“Obviously something happened to Kelsey,” Bott on Wednesday stated of the discrepancies between her testimony and the interview in September. “Something spooked her. Maybe somebody got to her. Maybe she took one of those bribes.”
However Mgdesyan painted Harris’ skittishness as worry of her personal culpability within the case
“She had an attorney, and every time she was questioned and grilled, they went through that door,” he stated, nodding to a hallway the place Harris fled from the stand a number of occasions final week.
Prosecutors have additionally pointed to voicemails and texts Peterson despatched to Harris and Pete during which he apologized for his conduct inside 24 hours of the incident, although he by no means really admits to against the law. Bott known as on jurors to make use of their frequent sense and infer the one factor he may have been sorry for was the capturing.
Whereas Mgdesyan has argued Harris despatched the texts to cowl for her crime, Bott known as that assertion preposterous.
“Is Kelsey some kind of criminal mastermind where she’s framing the defendant five minutes after the shooting?” Bott requested.
Mgdesyan stated Thursday that prosecutors had been too dismissive of testimony from Kelly, the neighbor who witnessed the altercation. However of their rebuttal, prosecutors drew closely from Kelly’s testimony.
Whereas Mgdesyan targeted on Kelly’s declare that noticed flashes from the place Harris was standing through the altercation, prosecutors reminded jurors that Kelly additionally testified he noticed “flashes” coming from the place “the short man” — presumably the diminutive Peterson — was standing.
Ta shared excerpts from Kelly’s earlier testimony, displaying that it was according to how prosecutors say the capturing unfolded: The quick man — Peterson — was standing exterior the automotive with two girls — Harris and Pete — when Kelly noticed the primary muzzle flashes; the quick man’s arm was outstretched when he noticed one of many flashes and had heard what he described as gunshots; and that the quick man had been upset, yelling obscenities on the girls.
Ta re-asserted the prosecution’s argument that Peterson had been motivated by jealousy and that Pete had “bruised his ego” as a rapper throughout a verbal argument contained in the automotive, main as much as the capturing.
Coming on the finish of a string of movie star trials within the courthouse that concerned disgraced Hollywood mogul Harvey Weinstein and former “That ‘70s Show” star Danny Masterson, Peterson’s trial has arguably attracted probably the most consideration.
The courtroom has been almost full day-after-day, with a few of Peterson’s followers lining the again of the gallery and heaping reward on the Ontario-born rapper within the hallway. Social media personalities usually spend lunch breaks arguing over Peterson’s guilt or innocence exterior the Fifteenth-floor courtroom. On the day Pete testified, quite a lot of girls staged a small rally on Temple Road to indicate help for her as a survivor of home violence.
“This whole story has not been about the shooting. It’s only been about who I been having sex with,” Pete testified final week, her voice cracking with frustration. “When people talk about Megan Thee Stallion getting shot, all the headlines are Megan Thee Stallion is on trial, and I’m not on trial!”